The most interesting thing about this book is how much worse it is than the film.The film is mysterious and beautiful, whereas in the book Dick tries to explain everything, the sci-fi writer's curse. Also the film's major themes are handled with some ambiguity - is the Deckard character a replicant, for instance, are the replicants actually a higher form of life, is Deckard justified in killing...
more The most interesting thing about this book is how much worse it is than the film.The film is mysterious and beautiful, whereas in the book Dick tries to explain everything, the sci-fi writer's curse. Also the film's major themes are handled with some ambiguity - is the Deckard character a replicant, for instance, are the replicants actually a higher form of life, is Deckard justified in killing the them, these are all questions that are offered to you in the film to think about. In the book Dick prefers to do most of the thinking for you.
The writing is only ok actually. There's some schoolboyish description.
I haven't read any other books by Dick, but I've liked all the film adaptations. Has anyone else noticed that Total Recall, Blade Runner and Through a Scanner Darkly are all the same story? Someone thinks they are part of the establishment, but turns out to be a part of the underclass they are persecuting.
The whole levels of reality thing - it's just the kind of thing you might start thinking about in the toilet at a party if you were on acid. ("They are all androids! Oh my god, I'm an android too"). But, you know, just don't do those kinds of drugs, I mean, if it's bothering you.
hide